Health Practitioners Reexamining the Effectiveness of Vitamin D Supplements
Robert Shmerling, MD, Faculty Editor for Harvard Health Publications, asks, “Vitamin D and physical function: Is more better?” He says the popularity of vitamin D has been surging in recent years, largely because of the growing list of its proposed health benefits. But not all of the claims are backed by evidence.
For example, there have been suggestions that vitamin D can help you
- reduce your risk of arthritis
- prevent heart disease
- improve your brain function and lessen your risk of dementia
- improve your immune function and lessen the risk of immune disorders.
“These are difficult claims to prove — or disprove,” Shmerling wrote. “Most of them come from studies linking a low intake of vitamin D or a low level in the blood with an increased risk of disease or death. But, it’s possible that people with low intake or blood levels of vitamin D levels also smoke more, exercise less, or have other explanations for their higher rates of disease and death.
“While it’s not at all clear that vitamin D can deliver these health benefits, getting enough vitamin D is important, especially for maintaining bone health. Severe deficiency of vitamin D can cause osteomalacia, which means “soft bones.” (In children, abnormal bone development due to vitamin D deficiency is called rickets.) Low levels of vitamin D can also contribute to osteoporosis: vitamin D is needed to promote calcium absorption in the gut, and calcium is essential in building and remodeling bone.”
Doctors need to make these benefits and deficiency risks clear to consumers. A great audience to target with straight talk about vitamin D would be Health/Doctor Talk Listeners. AudienceSCAN research reported 10.8% of U.S. adults enjoy listening to “Health/Doctor Talk” shows or audio programs via radio, Internet or podcast.
Can vitamin D also improve physical function?
“To explore the possibility that vitamin D might provide yet another health benefit, researchers recently published a study to determine whether taking a high dose vitamin D supplement might help stave off a decline in physical function in older adults,” Shmerling said. “Researchers enrolled 200 people who were at least age 70 and who had reported a fall in the past. Some were given a low dose of vitamin D, while others received higher doses. After a year, the researchers assessed the participants’ physical function (by measures of walking speed, ability to stand up repeatedly from a sitting position, and balance). The results were no better in those treated with higher doses of vitamin D than in those on lower doses. In addition, those receiving the higher doses reported significantly more falls. There was no clear explanation for this unexpected finding.”
“While this study casts doubt on vitamin D as a panacea for failing physical function among elderly adults, it’s still possible that it might help certain people — for example, perhaps younger adults who’ve never fallen before would see more benefit. Or, a longer period of follow-up might reveal other benefits associated with taking high-dose vitamin D supplements.”
Please stand by
“While we know vitamin D is an essential part of a healthy diet and supplements might be helpful for those who don’t get enough, we need more research to back up some of its proposed benefits. In the meantime, it seems reasonable to choose a balanced diet that contains the recommended daily amount of vitamin D for your age and gender. Sun exposure (perhaps as little as 10-15 minutes a day) may also increase blood levels of vitamin D because UVB radiation from the sun converts precursors of vitamin D in the skin.”
When you’re targeting Health/Doctor Talk Listeners about vitamin D recommendations for their age and gender, you should know that AudienceSCAN found 62.5% of Listeners are women. And 19.6% of these Listeners are aged 25-34, while 18.3% are aged 35-44.
“Read the reports about the health benefits of this vitamin (and other vitamins and supplements) with a skeptical eye. There is considerable uncertainty about what vitamin D can do for you — and, as demonstrated in this latest research, one thing is clear: more is not always better,” Shmerling recommended.